
Can Visualizing Success Help–and Hinder–Taking Action?
Why fantasies about the future sometimes reduce our readiness to act, how they differ from mental rehearsal, and how to connect a desired outcome with a real obstacle.

“Starting running on Monday,” “I’ll learn Spanish this year,” “I’m launching my own project.” We often share our plans with friends or followers, hoping for support and extra motivation. It seems that making a public promise increases accountability: once you’ve told people about your goal, backing out feels awkward. But the psychology of motivation is more complex.
Research shows that announcing an intention alone does not guarantee that you will follow through. What’s more, in some situations, social recognition can create a premature sense of accomplishment–as if a person has already moved closer to the desired outcome, even though they haven’t done anything yet.
That doesn’t mean sharing your goals is necessarily harmful. What matters much more is what happens after the conversation. If the people around you help track your progress, support consistent action, or offer feedback, a public commitment can become a useful tool.
The key distinction is between talking about an intention and reporting on actual actions. Research gives us more reason to expect benefits from regularly tracking progress than from the motivating effect of simply announcing plans. Let’s explore when it’s worth talking about your goals–and when it may be better to start taking action first.
The Wake Up New Month video format combines a personal promise with a later check-in. In a review dated November 9, 2026, the commercial service Social Expert reported more than 34 million views recorded for related videos. This indicates interest in the format; it doesn’t tell us how many people made a promise or how many reached their goal.
The structure proposed by the service has three elements: a specific goal, showing the first action, and returning to the same scene to report on what has changed. From a psychological perspective, the combination of an announcement and a check-in on the outcome is interesting. A video might stop at an image of your future self, or it might mark the beginning of a series of actions and reports.
The format itself cannot yet be considered a proven method for reaching goals. But it raises a useful question: what does a person actually get from making a goal public? Congratulations for making the decision, practical help, or a reason to regularly notice what they’ve accomplished?
The idea that “talking about a goal makes you lose motivation” is often linked to a study by Peter Gollwitzer and colleagues, published in Psychological Science in 2009. The researchers conducted four small experiments involving intentions tied to a desired identity, such as wanting to become a lawyer.
In the first three experiments, participants whose intentions were noticed by others then engaged less intensely in activities related to those intentions. In the fourth, attention to an intention increased participants’ premature sense that they already possessed the desired identity.
The authors proposed one explanation: acknowledgment from another person may partially satisfy the need to feel like the person you want to become. The statement “I’m going to become a lawyer” receives social recognition, bringing the person a little closer to their desired self-image in their own eyes, even though the work required is still ahead.
It’s important to note that the researchers examined attention to an intention. They did not establish a specific effect of likes, enthusiastic comments, or praise. So the explanation “I got approval and didn’t want to do anything else” oversimplifies the findings.
In addition, the experiments mainly focused on students’ professional identities and used small samples. They help explain one possible mechanism, but they don’t justify keeping all plans to yourself. Talking about a desired career, asking for help preparing for an exam, and reporting on work completed can have different effects.
When you give an update, the subject of the conversation changes. Instead of discussing who you intend to become, you share what has happened: how many sessions you completed, what part of the project is ready, or where you ran into difficulty. This information lets you compare your plan with reality and decide what to do next.
Benjamin Harkin and colleagues assessed the benefits of this kind of tracking in a meta-analysis of 138 randomized studies involving nearly 20,000 people. Published in Psychological Bulletin in 2016, the study found that interventions encouraging people to monitor their progress improved goal attainment on average.
The effect was greater when participants recorded their results in writing and shared them with others. And it was enough to report to at least one person–there was no need for a large audience.
This makes the distinction between a promise and a report practically useful. “I’ve decided to write a book” communicates an intention. “I drafted one scene this week and figured out where I got stuck” gives you something to work with when deciding what to do next. Even a lack of progress can be informative if you can discuss it calmly.
At the same time, making a goal public doesn’t necessarily get in the way. In a 2017 meta-analysis by Tracy Epton and colleagues, public goal setting was one of the conditions associated with more effective goal pursuit.
Both meta-analyses compared features across different studies. They don’t provide a direct experimental answer to whether announcing an intention is better or worse than regularly reporting on progress, all else being equal. The more defensible conclusion is that tracking actions is useful, while the effects of making a goal public depend on how you do it.

There’s another reason to share your plans: the people around you may be able to help. Someone close to you might make time for your practice, talk through a difficult part of your work, or listen after an unsuccessful attempt. For this kind of help to be possible, they usually need to know what you’re working on.
Johanna Peetz, Roger Buehler, and Taylor Wells explored this aspect of sharing goals in their study, Goals Out Loud, published online in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin in 2025. It combined four longitudinal studies. The authors examined important long-term goals and conversations primarily with people close to the participants.
In two studies, instructions to talk about a goal were accompanied by greater support received. Support, in turn, was associated with greater effort. However, in these two studies, the direct effect of the instructions themselves on effort was not statistically significant. Some participants in the control groups also talked about their goals, making comparisons more difficult.
So the study supports the possibility of getting help through conversation, but it doesn’t promise that being open will automatically make you more productive. Nor can its results be directly applied to posts aimed at an audience of strangers.
The practical takeaway is simple: before you talk about your goal, think about what kind of support you need. A request like “I need an hour on Tuesdays without household chores” gives the other person more ways to help than a general statement like “I’m getting serious about learning a language.”
The following approach brings together findings on progress tracking and social support. It’s a practical way to organize your work, not a universally validated protocol in its own right.
Choose an action for the coming period. Instead of “speak Spanish fluently,” you could plan three short study sessions this week. The workload should fit your schedule. A long-term goal can remain your guiding direction, but your check-in should focus on what you can do now.
Decide what information you’ll record. For learning, this might be the sessions you completed and a specific difficulty; for a writing project, a finished section and the next step. Consider what the work actually involves: the number of lessons you opened doesn’t tell you whether you’ve learned the material.
Set a clear time to revisit the conversation. For example, send a brief message on Friday evening. Agree on three questions: What did you plan? What did you accomplish? What’s one adjustment worth making? Choose a frequency that doesn’t take time away from the work itself.
Discuss the other person’s role. Do you need questions, help thinking through an obstacle, or just someone to read your update attentively? Check whether the person is willing to take part. Not everyone close to you wants to–or is able to–keep track of someone else’s project on a regular basis.
It’s useful to agree in advance on how to discuss a gap between the plan and the outcome. If you completed one session instead of three, you can look at what got in the way: unsuitable timing, too much to do, or changed circumstances. That way, the report still serves its purpose of providing information.
You don’t need a public platform for this kind of arrangement. One person who agrees to check in with you also meets the definition of reporting used in Harkin’s meta-analysis. If you like sharing publicly, keep the same structure: promise, completed action, next step. The number of viewers doesn’t replace any of these elements.
Look at what you do between check-ins. Have actions made it onto your schedule? Is it clearer where you get stuck? Have you received the help you asked for? These questions are more useful than judging how inspired you feel right after posting.
If preparing an update regularly takes more time than working toward your goal, you can simplify the format. For example, replace an edited video with a short message to one person. If the conversation keeps centering on an image of future success, bring it back to the next action and a specific obstacle.
One successful or unsuccessful period isn’t enough to establish what effect, if any, making your goal public had on the outcome: your workload, available time, and task difficulty may all change at once. This kind of self-check can help you adjust your arrangement to suit you, but it doesn’t replace an experiment.
You don’t have to choose between keeping everything secret and making a promise to all your followers. You can tell one person about your goal, share your first result later, and only then decide whether you want a wider audience. Each conversation can have its own purpose: getting help, discussing a difficulty, or recording what you’ve done.
Yes. A public promise doesn’t require you to stick with a goal that is no longer meaningful or achievable. In your update, you can explain what has changed and what you’re reconsidering: the timeline, the workload, or the goal itself. It’s better to be clear about this than to keep up an old promise just to maintain an image of consistency.
Return to the arrangement from where you are now. Briefly say what you managed to do and why you didn’t check in. If this keeps happening, reconsider the frequency or format: the process itself may be too cumbersome. Missing a message and not taking action are worth discussing separately.
No. You don’t need to be pursuing the same outcome to check in with someone. A person familiar with the task may be helpful for discussing technical details; special expertise may not be necessary to receive a short update or help you organize your time. The key is to agree in advance on what kind of participation you’re hoping for.
How was this article?
Share