Impostor Syndrome and Vulnerable Narcissism: What Connects Them?

Published on: ⋄8 min read
Author: Valeriia Voronova, Editor at SOD Energy
Achievement and dependence on external recognition as different aspects of how we experience our competence

A person may fear that others overestimate their abilities while also having a strong need for recognition. Psychologist Christina Klug and her colleagues found that impostor experiences are noticeably associated with vulnerable narcissism, which is characterized by sensitivity to evaluation and self-esteem that depends on how others respond. One possible point of overlap is that other people's approval becomes necessary confirmation of one's worth, but does not provide lasting inner confidence.

At the same time, the researchers distinguished between the two traits. Impostor syndrome does not make someone a narcissist, and the association they found does not yet explain why these experiences occur together.

What Is Meant by Impostor Syndrome?

Impostor syndrome, or the impostor phenomenon, describes an experience in which one's achievements seem like insufficient evidence of competence. A person may attribute success to luck, help from others, or having made a good impression. The next challenging task feels like a test that will finally reveal their inadequacy.

For example, an employee successfully completes several projects but believes they were simply given easy assignments. A promotion heightens their anxiety: expectations are now higher, and there are fewer opportunities to hide their presumed incompetence. This is a hypothetical example, not a description of everyone who feels nervous about starting a new job.

The impostor phenomenon is not a psychiatric diagnosis in its own right. The word “syndrome” here does not mean that a person has an illness. Doubts may be situational or persistent, arising in one area while being almost entirely absent in another.

The actual circumstances also matter. A newcomer may genuinely lack certain knowledge, while an experienced professional may need help with an unfamiliar task. Acknowledging a specific gap is different from believing that all of one's previous successes were due to chance.

What Is Vulnerable Narcissism?

Narcissism is often portrayed as conspicuous confidence, a sense of superiority, and a desire to be the center of attention. This image is closer to grandiose narcissism. Vulnerable narcissism can look different: anxiety, shame, defensive reactions, avoidance of situations involving evaluation, and painful sensitivity to rejection.

In a review by Emanuel Jauk and Philipp Kanske, self-esteem that depends on how others respond and the concealment of one's weaknesses are described as components of narcissistic vulnerability. Outward reserve does not necessarily mean inner independence from recognition.

But vulnerable narcissism cannot be reduced to shyness or low self-esteem. It also involves beliefs about one's special importance and entitlement to special treatment. A person may struggle to accept that others do not notice their exceptional qualities or offer the recognition they expect.

It is this broader pattern that distinguishes narcissistic personality traits from an ordinary need for support. Wanting to hear praise, feeling ashamed after a mistake, or reacting painfully to criticism does not, by itself, indicate a diagnosis. Narcissism cannot be inferred from a single experience, however intense it may be.

What Connection Did the Researchers Find?

The study by Christina Klug and her colleagues, published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin in 2026, included 339 German-speaking participants, most of whom were women. Participants completed online questionnaires about impostor experiences, narcissistic traits, relationships, and memories of their upbringing.

The stronger a person's impostor self-concept–that is, their view of themselves as someone whose competence is overestimated–the higher their vulnerable narcissism scores tended to be. The association with grandiose narcissism was noticeably weaker.

However, a statistical model that treated impostor experiences, vulnerable narcissism, and grandiose narcissism as separate traits described participants' responses better than a model that combined the first two. In other words, the experiences overlapped substantially, but they were not interchangeable.

The study measured traits, not diagnosed narcissistic personality disorder. A one-time online survey cannot establish causality; self-reports and the predominantly female sample also limit the conclusions. These data cannot tell us what proportion of people with impostor syndrome have narcissistic traits or a clinical diagnosis.

Partial overlap between impostor experiences and vulnerable narcissism
A strong association between two traits does not make them one and the same.

Why Recognition May Not Strengthen Self-Esteem

One possible explanation for the overlap has to do with the role recognition plays. Feedback helps us assess our work and understand what went well. But if our sense of worth depends on it, every evaluation takes on much greater weight: a comment about a specific result starts to sound like a verdict on the whole person.

Suppose a professional receives praise for a presentation. They feel reassured for a little while, then think: “They just didn't notice the weak points.” Before the next meeting, they feel they have to prove again that they deserve to be treated well. Vulnerable narcissistic traits may add the feeling that recognition should be exceptional, and that insufficient attention means disregard.

Here, it is useful to distinguish high standards from perfectionistic concerns: fear of mistakes, doubts about the quality of one's actions, and a painful sense of falling short of expectations. In a meta-analysis by Andrew Hill and John Gotwals, which combined 25 studies and more than 12,000 participants, impostor experiences were much more closely associated with these concerns than with striving for perfection itself.

A related finding comes from a meta-analysis by Silvia Casale and her colleagues: striving to present oneself to others as perfect was associated, among other things, with vulnerable narcissism.

These findings help us formulate a hypothesis about a shared dynamic: a person tries to maintain a flawless image, hides their doubts, and becomes increasingly dependent on external evaluation. But the meta-analyses did not test a causal chain between narcissism and impostor syndrome. This is a possible explanation for the overlap, not an established single mechanism.

The Role of Relationships and the Workplace

In Klug's study, both traits were associated with greater attachment anxiety and less trust in others. Attachment anxiety means worrying that important people will reject us, pull away, or stop supporting us. In this context, other people's evaluations can feel like both welcome support and a potential threat.

The authors also found that both traits were associated with memories of parental control and overprotection. But adults' memories cannot reconstruct their upbringing with complete accuracy or establish that it caused their current experiences. The results of this survey do not justify blaming parents.

In addition, doubts about one's competence arise within a specific environment. In an umbrella review in Medical Education that brought together 16 reviews, the authors highlight the role of hierarchies and exclusion from professional communities.

If a professional is regularly interrupted, excluded from discussions, or evaluated according to opaque rules, their doubts cannot be explained solely by their personality. Sometimes a person genuinely lacks clear feedback, training, or equal access to opportunities. Working only on self-esteem will not change these conditions.

What You Can Do About the Fear of Being Exposed

To start, it is more helpful to examine specific situations than to search for a hidden personality type. The following steps can help make the experience more concrete. They are guidelines for self-reflection, not a validated treatment protocol for the combination of these two traits.

  1. Pinpoint exactly what exposure you fear. For example: “I won't be able to answer a question about a topic I haven't worked on yet.” Then distinguish a gap in specific knowledge from the general conclusion, “I have no right to hold this position.” You can make a learning plan to address the first; the second calls for looking at a broader range of evidence.

  2. Ask for feedback on specific actions. Instead of asking, “Am I a good professional at all?” ask, “Which part of the report is convincing, and where does it need more supporting evidence?” A specific response gives you something to work with and depends less on the other person's general impression of you.

  3. Assess your contribution without going to extremes. After completing a task, list what you did yourself, where colleagues helped, and what role circumstances played. Recognizing help does not negate your own competence. You don't have to choose between “I did it all myself” and “I just got lucky.”

  4. Notice what insufficient recognition means to you. If a colleague is praised and you aren't, what is your first thought: “My contribution went unnoticed,” “I'm worse,” or “They should have singled me out”? These reactions can coexist, but they point to different questions: the visibility of your work, your self-esteem, or an expectation of special treatment.

  5. Agree on what counts as a good enough result before starting a task. Discuss the scope, deadline, and acceptable degree of uncertainty. This is especially helpful if you keep revising your work in an effort to eliminate any possibility of criticism. For tasks where mistakes could be dangerous, the criteria should reflect professional requirements.

It is better to assess change through behavior: Has it become easier to ask questions, accept specific feedback, finish work, and acknowledge other people's contributions? You do not need to eliminate the need for approval entirely.

When to Reach Out to a Psychologist

It may be helpful to seek support if fear of evaluation leads you to turn down opportunities, overwork, avoid people, or regularly get into conflicts. Another reason to seek help may be a recurring cycle: recognition brings brief relief, then shame, anxiety, or resentment returns, and relationships are strained again.

In a consultation, it is useful to discuss specific episodes: what happened, how you interpreted it, and what you did afterward. This is more informative than starting with the label “narcissistic personality type”. Similar experiences can be sustained by different causes, and support should take into account your own recurring patterns, relationships, and living conditions.

Can an online test tell me exactly what's going on with me?

No, an online test cannot reliably distinguish between these experiences or provide a diagnosis. A questionnaire may suggest topics to discuss, but its results depend on the scale used and the context. There is still no single definition or gold-standard measure for the impostor phenomenon.

Can someone with these experiences actually be competent?

Yes. Impostor experiences and narcissistic traits do not determine a person's professional skill level. Competence is assessed through the quality of one's work, knowledge, and actions. A need for recognition also proves neither exceptional ability nor a lack of it.

Do I need to tell my manager I have impostor syndrome?

No, you don't have to use that label. If the issue is work-related, you can discuss a specific need: clear criteria for results, training, regular feedback, or how responsibilities are distributed. How much to share about your experiences depends on how much you trust your manager and how safe your workplace feels.

How was this article?

 

Share

Explore more